Comments on: Andover War Memorial – Is It Time for a Referendum? https://www.andovertown.co.uk/news/andover-war-memorial-is-it-time-for-a-referendum/ Andover, Hampshire, UK Thu, 03 Oct 2013 14:11:23 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=7.0.8 By: Mark Brown https://www.andovertown.co.uk/news/andover-war-memorial-is-it-time-for-a-referendum/#comment-2222 Thu, 03 Oct 2013 14:11:23 +0000 http://www.andovertown.co.uk/?p=3624#comment-2222 In reply to Martin Emmerson.

Not really sure what you mean by ‘Memorial Garden’, Martin. It is already the ‘Garden of Remembrance’, what would be the difference? It all sounds like a bit of a throw-away line. Who would organise it, TVBC, the Town Council, the Church, the Education Authority? And what would it entail/look like? Similar things have been suggested in the past, really as just a way of deflecting from the real issue at hand. For example, almost three years ago now TVBC said, that as a compromise (a compromise, really?) to the “return it” campaign, they and the Town Council would look to improve access (realising that it is not an ideal location for large crowds to gather) and also sight lines. The idea was to remove the trees at the rear of the memorial and maybe look to put in new steps up from Newbury Street. It was really just a deflection of the issue at hand and obviously nothing has actually happened. Another was the idea of a new memorial in the churchyard (not sure how that would satisfy the calls to put the cenotaph back?), to commemorate all those Andoverians that have died since the end of the Second World War. Someone did some research and found only one (and it is a real shame he does not already have a memorial in the town), and again nothing has actually happened. I fear your suggestion, however well intended, would suffer the same fate. To my mind the memorial should either stay as it is or be put back where it came from. And the only way to decide that is by some kind of referendum. After that, if it stays, other options can be considered as appropriate (I would not hold my breath), but at the moment I believe that such ‘compromises’ are just a way of deflecting attention away from the ever growing calls to see the memorial returened to the high street. Let’s sort out the issue at hand first, that of whether or not it should be put back, before we go off chasing other dreams.

]]>
By: Martin Emmerson https://www.andovertown.co.uk/news/andover-war-memorial-is-it-time-for-a-referendum/#comment-2221 Wed, 02 Oct 2013 23:26:00 +0000 http://www.andovertown.co.uk/?p=3624#comment-2221 I think what would be a great idea is to turn its current location into a memorial garden, with the memorial pride of place. Get the community involved and turn it into a project, get the kids involved too what a great way of making them feel part of the community. This would really be a fantastic way of getting the message out there to the young persons and the adults of Andover, and with that little education and understanding would come the respect and appreciation that the memorial truly deserves and there would also be a sense of pride to everybody that would help create and maintain the memorial garden.

]]>
By: Bob Roberts https://www.andovertown.co.uk/news/andover-war-memorial-is-it-time-for-a-referendum/#comment-2220 Wed, 02 Oct 2013 20:40:12 +0000 http://www.andovertown.co.uk/?p=3624#comment-2220 Some time ago Councillor Nigel Long (Lib Dem) stated on his website that he was going to conduct a survey regarding whether the memorial should be returned or not amongst his constituents in St Mary’s ward…

http://nigellong.mycouncillor.org.uk/2013/02/12/andovers-war-memorial/

Anyone know what became of that?

I think a referendum is the best way to bring this important issue to a proper conclusion.

]]>
By: John Riley https://www.andovertown.co.uk/news/andover-war-memorial-is-it-time-for-a-referendum/#comment-2219 Wed, 02 Oct 2013 17:29:39 +0000 http://www.andovertown.co.uk/?p=3624#comment-2219 Jayne, there is a lot of truth in what you say. But I think the bad feeling and polarisation comes from the fact the TVBC are just burying their heads in the sand, hoping the issue will go away.

However, as for as many people wanting it left alone as want it returned, that does not appear to be the case, whatever Cllr Carr would like to have us think. Looking at the letters page of the AA there are definitely more people moved to write in who are in favour of returning it. The poll the AA ran also showed a majority in favour of putting it back. They prove nothing on their own, but are probably a good barometer of the feelings of the residents that care, one way or another.

I think if a referendum was held, as suggested here, it could sort this issue out once and for all. I personally think it should be returned, but if the people of the town, and not just Mr Carr, say leave it alone, then I would be happy with that. This issue raised its head again about 4 years ago, and hasn’t gone away really since. That must say something for the strong feelings in favour of a return. Surely, it must be worth some sort of poll/vote to finally settle the issue once and for all?

The really sad thing here is that once again lots of people feel they are being ignored by the council.

]]>
By: Mark Brown https://www.andovertown.co.uk/news/andover-war-memorial-is-it-time-for-a-referendum/#comment-2218 Wed, 02 Oct 2013 15:09:57 +0000 http://www.andovertown.co.uk/?p=3624#comment-2218 In reply to Martin Emmerson.

The point is just to return the memorial to where the people who lost sons, brothers and fathers and who paid for it to be erected outside the Guildhall placed it and wanted it to be seen. Putting it somewhere else in the high street would be as bad as putting it in the churchyard. But as you’ve asked, I think it would look good at the bottom of the high street, looking up towards the Guildhall. The parade could march up Bridge Street for the Remembrance Day Service and it satisfies the need for a town centre location. But that’s just my opinion and there are as many of those as there are people in the town. Can you imagine putting it there and then in 50 years there is a campaign to get it relocated again to outside the Guildhall? Ha, we’d be viewed as no better than Andover Borough Council in the 1950s. The only option with any real credence, based on the facts at hand, is to put it back where it was.

]]>
By: Jayne Sylvest https://www.andovertown.co.uk/news/andover-war-memorial-is-it-time-for-a-referendum/#comment-2217 Wed, 02 Oct 2013 13:52:22 +0000 http://www.andovertown.co.uk/?p=3624#comment-2217 It does tend to come down to a matter of opinion. While I appreciate that some people would like to see the return of the memorial to it’s former position in front of the Guildhall, there are just as many that appreciate where it is now situated.

It isn’t “out of sight, out of mind” for the people that consider the sad spectacle of war. For those that don’t care about such things it’s presence in the High Street is unlikely to make them so.

Personally, I prefer where it is but it wouldn’t cause me any great consternation if it is moved. The financial issue of moving it isn’t really an issue as there’s been an offer to move it with no cost to residents. What I find unpalatable is that the issue seems to bring out quite an amount of ugliness in people.

Wherever the memorial rests it is becoming inbibed with bad feelings. Sad.

]]>
By: Martin Emmerson https://www.andovertown.co.uk/news/andover-war-memorial-is-it-time-for-a-referendum/#comment-2216 Wed, 02 Oct 2013 11:40:57 +0000 http://www.andovertown.co.uk/?p=3624#comment-2216 In reply to Mark Brown.

Not neccesarely ruin the facade, that would all depend on the ability of the architect employed to do that job, and even it would come down to a matter of opinion.

You are obviously very passionate about this Mark but don’t get blinkered by the thought that the only way people can show their appreciation and respect is by moving its location. Is your argument that it has to go back to its original spot or just that it is returned to the town center. What about locating it at the other end of town near bridge street?

]]>
By: Mark Brown https://www.andovertown.co.uk/news/andover-war-memorial-is-it-time-for-a-referendum/#comment-2215 Tue, 01 Oct 2013 20:22:00 +0000 http://www.andovertown.co.uk/?p=3624#comment-2215 In reply to Martin Emmerson.

It was relocated because the council wanted to extend the ground floor of the Guildhall, which would have ruined that facade you are talking about! Luckily, it did not happen, but by then it was too late, the memorial and the men and the history it represents had been banished from sight. The sooner it is back where it should be the better.

As for looking out of place, check out pictures of the two together It was designed to match architecturally the Guildhall, not the flint knappping of the church.

Happy for everyone to have an opinion, but need to remember this campaign is about facts, not opinion.

]]>
By: Martin Emmerson https://www.andovertown.co.uk/news/andover-war-memorial-is-it-time-for-a-referendum/#comment-2205 Mon, 30 Sep 2013 22:37:15 +0000 http://www.andovertown.co.uk/?p=3624#comment-2205 In reply to Simon Wilberforce.

Exactly, just because people may not want it in the town center that doesn’t mean they don’t respect the sacrifice that others have made. The guildhall is a beautiful building and iconic to Andover town center. With the memorial moved In front of the guildhall, it would not only look out of place but would obscure the buildings attractive facade. The move would also be costly, money would be better spent else where even put towards the maintenance costs of its current location. It’s in a good spot, has anybody sought to ask as to why it was relocated in the first place?

]]>
By: Mark Brown https://www.andovertown.co.uk/news/andover-war-memorial-is-it-time-for-a-referendum/#comment-2204 Mon, 30 Sep 2013 21:58:02 +0000 http://www.andovertown.co.uk/?p=3624#comment-2204 What’s with the “place of reflection”? The memorial was designed to be seen in a busy high street, not hidden away. Graffiti? Only place a war memorial has ever been graffitied in Andover is in the churchyard. And let’s not forget that it only needed protective railings AFTER it was moved. One thing you can say about the council and the high street, there ain’t no litter!

]]>